Back to blog
Preventive maintenance

Car myths: warming up the engine, premium gas, and water in the radiator

JuanBy the Soy Juan Mecánico team5 min read

Some car advice gets passed from parents to kids without anyone questioning it. Some of it made sense with older cars. Some of it never did. And one piece can be expensive, or dangerous.

We looked at three of the most common: warming up the engine for ten minutes before driving, filling up with premium for more power, and pouring cold water into the radiator when the engine overheats.

Juan tells you in a minute

Three things your dad taught you about cars. How many are myths? (Video in Spanish.)

1. Warm up the car for 10 minutes before driving: it depends

If your car is fuel-injected, which is almost everything built in the last 25 years (if you're not sure, check the owner's manual or ask your mechanic), there's no need. And leaving it idling for ten minutes isn't harmless: with a cold engine the mixture is richer, and gasoline washes the oil film off the cylinder walls and dilutes the oil. It's slow wear, not a breakdown, but more than a few minutes of idling can shorten the engine's life.

What does make sense: start it, wait about 30 seconds (by then the engine is already lubricated) and drive gently, without pushing it, until the temperature needle reaches its normal spot. That way it warms up faster and more evenly than sitting still.

If your car has a carburetor, your dad's rule had a point: then it's worth waiting a minute or two before driving off.

2. Premium gas gives any car more power: myth

If your owner's manual calls for the lower-octane fuel, filling up with premium gives you neither more power nor more miles per gallon. An AAA dynamometer study, with engines designed for the lower-octane fuel, found no difference in power, fuel economy or emissions. Consumer Reports and Kia say the same.

The key is the word any. The manual is what counts:

  • If it says premium is required, use it.
  • If it says premium is recommended, there may be a small gain.
  • If it calls for the lower-octane fuel, premium adds nothing.

What if my car knocks on the lower-octane fuel? That's a different problem. If the gas you can get is off-spec and the engine knocks, a higher-octane fuel from a reliable station can stop the knocking. That doesn't contradict the myth: premium isn't giving it more power, the other fuel just wasn't right.

3. If it overheats, pour cold water into the radiator: myth, and dangerous

This is the costly one. Cold water on an overheated engine causes a sudden temperature change that can crack or warp the cylinder head or the block. And opening the cap while the system is hot and under pressure can release a jet of boiling coolant and cause burns.

What you should do instead

1

Pull over somewhere safe and turn off the engine

Every minute it keeps running overheated can add damage.

2

Never open the cap while it's hot

Wait for the engine to cool down: it can take half an hour or more.

3

With the engine cold, check the level

Check it in the reservoir. In older cars without one, check it at the radiator, always cold, with a thick rag over the cap, loosening it slowly.

4

Have it checked before driving on

If it overheated, there's a cause (a leak, the water pump, the fan, the thermostat) that topping up won't fix. The safest option is to tow it.

Full step by step in Steam coming from the hood? What to do (and not do).

Juan

“Were you taught another one? Tell me with your car's make and year, and I'll tell you whether it applies.”

Which one were you taught?

Sorry, Dad. Ask Juan anything about your car: he answers instantly, for your car's make and model, no mechanical knowledge needed.

No sign-up. No card. Available now.

Frequently asked questions

How long should I warm up the engine before driving?

In a fuel-injected car, about 30 seconds is enough: then drive gently until the temperature needle reaches its normal spot. Idling for ten minutes isn't necessary and causes more engine wear. In a carbureted car, it's worth waiting a minute or two.

Is premium gas worth it?

Only if your owner's manual calls for it. If it calls for the lower-octane fuel, premium gives you neither more power nor better mileage. If the manual lists it as recommended, there may be a small gain.

Can I pour cold water into the radiator if the engine overheated?

No. The sudden temperature change can crack the cylinder head or the block, and opening the cap while hot can cause burns. Turn off the engine, wait for it to cool down and check the level cold. Since overheating has a cause, the safest option is to have it checked before driving on.

How long should I wait before opening the radiator cap?

Until the engine is cold: it can take half an hour or more. Never open it hot, because the system is under pressure.

Juan